Best of Responses and Reactions

[ IQ Shen Home | History | Participate | The Test | Credits | Responses ]


Date: Tue, 8 Mar 94 19:48:31 -0500
Subject: iq test

Do you remember where you got that test?  On traditional tests I score really
high but this one kicked my ass and I would love to see some explanations...
Do you remember where you found it perchance?


Date: Fri, 11 Mar 1994 08:08:31 -0800 (PST)
Subject: Your I.Q. Test (fwd) :)

I got this response from a friend who received the IQ
test from me.  Thought you might find it amusing, as his reaction was
just what I had hoped:

> Okay, I have many, many problems with your I.Q. Test:
> 
> 1) What scale doe the "I.Q. of 140" does it refer to? The WAIS-R, the 
> WISC-R, WAIS, WISC, the Stanford-Binet, the Binet-Simon, etc? Which one?
> 
> 2) "the I.Q. of 140"....how many standards of deviation (z-scores) above 
> mean is it?
> 
> 3) Why is the person who wrote the "test" using that scale and not one he 
> devised himself? Why not create your own bell curve for that test?
> 
> There are many more questions I could ask you about that I.Q. test you 
> sent me.  I.Q. tests are so...unpredictable...It figures in the 
> education, experience, environment and many more other things into the 
> test that not everyone would have in their life.  It assumes that you're 
> educated and thus if you pass the test, you're more "smarter" than the 
> rest....WRONG!!!! It just means that your total life experiences and 
> education has been more than a majority of people is THIS SOCIETY.  This 
> test is a VERY ETHONOCENTRIC test and CANNOT be applied to ANY OTHER 
> CULTURE OTHER THAN NORTH AMERICA AND SOME OF EUROPE.  It CANNOT be 
> applied to developing countries in Africa or Asia or anywhere in the 
> world thus it is NOT a TRUE measure of intelligence.
> 
> I've got more but I want to see what you think of that
   
:)  

What do you think?


[ IQ Shen Home | History | Participate | The Test | Credits | Responses ]


Back to Jabberwock's Lair

Last updated 5/13/96 by Jabberwock.